Blog

Best insurance agency answering services for quotes and claims

4 min read

  • Zach KamranCo-Founder & CTO
An evening call asking for a car insurance quote ends with a complete quote intake handed to a licensed agent.
In this article
TL;DR

An insurance answering service has to know where to stop, since only licensed staff can quote, bind, or give coverage advice. Most services handle that by taking a message. Simple collects complete quote and claim intake, follows your identity, disclosure, and licensing rules, and hands licensed work to licensed staff with the file already filled in.

Insurance calls come with rules. A quote needs complete information, a claim needs a structured first notice of loss, and only licensed staff can give coverage advice or bind a policy. A shopper who calls at 8 p.m. is often collecting other quotes the same night, so a message for a producer to return in the morning can cost you the policy.

Where the AI should stop

The line is the same for every service on this list. The AI collects information, and licensed people make coverage decisions. What differs is how complete the file is when it reaches them, and whether anyone checks that the required disclosures were read on every call.

ServiceBuilt forWho sets it up
SimpleInsurers and agencies with real call volumeSimple’s launch team, with your compliance rules built in
SonantP&C agencies and brokersSonant, with your agency guidelines
Smith.aiIndependent agentsYou on Pro; Smith.ai on Enterprise
GoodcallSmall to mid-size agenciesYou, with a no-code builder
PoshSmall businesses, including agenciesPosh, from your call instructions
UpfirstSmall businesses, including agenciesYou

1. Simple

Simple answers every call on the first ring, day or night, in 80 languages and dialects. For new business, it collects the approved quote information and routes a complete lead to a licensed agent. For a first notice of loss, it gathers the policy and loss details, requests supporting documents, checks claim status, and creates a structured intake record before the adjuster opens the file.

Quoting, binding, coverage advice, disputes, and unusual cases go to licensed staff with the transcript, intake, and identity check attached. Before launch, your team sets the required fields, identity checks, disclosures, and escalation paths, and Simple follows them on every call. Develop then scores every call, AI or human, for required language, complete intake, and correct transfers.

Our launch team builds and tests the workflow with your claims, sales, compliance, and IT teams, including edge cases like missing policy numbers and fraud indicators. Simple is SOC 2 Type II and HIPAA compliant and masks card numbers and personal details as the call happens. In consumer financial services, J.G. Wentworth turned 16% of outbound calls into applications.

2. Sonant

Sonant is an AI receptionist for P&C agencies, brokers, and distributors, built around entering call details into agency management systems. Its own cost post notes that “implementation and integration costs may still apply.” Its FAQ says that while it “excels at routine tasks and inquiries, it can also transfer complex cases to human agents,” and it serves insurance only.

3. Smith.ai

Smith.ai’s service for independent insurance agents pairs an AI receptionist with live receptionists. Its insurance page has the AI handling “routine appointment scheduling” and live receptionists taking “sensitive claims discussions, complex policy questions.” Every answered call is billed, $2.00 a call on Pro with spam counted by default, and custom prompting and integrations start on Enterprise at $500 a month.

4. Goodcall

Goodcall’s insurance page lists it as best for “small to mid-size agencies” and says it’s “built for SMBs; large carrier operations may need enterprise-level infrastructure.” The same page says its per-caller pricing “can add up for agencies with high new-lead volume.” You build and adjust the agent’s logic yourself, with a cap on how many tools you can connect.

5. Posh

Posh offers live and AI receptionists, and its insurance page covers screening calls, booking appointments, and collecting payments. Plans are minute bundles from $65 to $1,900 a month, with minutes over plan costing up to $2.30 live and $1.15 AI, and they’re labeled for startups, entrepreneurs, and small businesses. Most of what it does is transfer callers, schedule, and take messages.

6. Upfirst

Upfirst’s insurance page covers quote requests and payment links by text. For licensed questions it has you “tell it never to confirm coverage,” and it “takes the details and sends the message to an agent.” It bills per answered call, 30 to 600 calls a month, and you train and test it yourself.

Sonant, Smith.ai, Goodcall, Posh, and Upfirst are described from their own websites as of November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Can an AI answering service give coverage advice?

It shouldn’t, and Simple doesn’t. Only licensed staff give coverage advice or bind policies. Simple collects the approved information, then routes quoting, binding, and coverage questions to a licensed agent with the intake and transcript attached.

Is Simple compliant for insurance calls?

Simple is SOC 2 Type II and HIPAA compliant, encrypts recordings and transcripts with AES-256, and redacts card numbers and personal details in real time. Your required disclosures and identity checks are part of the workflow and scored on every call.

How do insurance answering services bill?

Mostly per call or per minute. Smith.ai’s AI Pro plan is $2.00 a call, and Posh sells minute bundles from $65 a month. Simple’s pricing follows business outcomes, like quotes handed to a licensed agent.

Put your best rep on every call

Tell us how your customers buy. We’ll show you where Simple can start winning revenue.